Misconceptions about the Middle Ages, Debunked through Art History
By The Iris
We got a kick out of this recent io9 post fact-checking 10 misconceptions about the Middle Ages. Drawing on a particularly awesome reddit/AskHistorians thread, the post untangles popular myths about the “Dark Ages,” including that peasants were all the same (NOT), and that women never pursued a trade (FAKE).
As manuscripts curators who spend our days studying the visual evidence of the Middle Ages (and our nights watching fantasy shows), we’d like to offer yet more visual ammo to debunk four of our favorite myths.
Post by Bryan C. Keene and Rheagan Martin, 3 Minute Read
Cover image: Detail of The Trinity, Book of Planets, Anatomical Treatise, Liber synonimorum, shortly after 1464. German. The J. Paul Getty Museum
The Iris: Behind The Scenes At The Getty
CC BY 4.0
NoteStreams are readable online but they’re even better in the free App!
The NoteStream™ app is for learning about things that interest you: from music to history, to classic literature or cocktails. NoteStreams are truly easy to read on your smartphone—so you can learn more about the world around you and start a fresh conversation.
For a list of all authors on NoteStream, click here.
Read the NoteStream below, or download the app and read it on the go!
The Temperate and the Intemperate, about 1475–80, Master of the Dresden Prayer Book. Flemish. The J. Paul Getty Museum
FALSE: People had horrible table manners, throwing bones and scraps on the floor
Pretty much every fantasy/medieval story has that “Scene In A Rowdy Inn” where filthy travelers guzzle beer and gnaw the meat off giant bones. But in the Middle Ages, there were indeed rules for etiquette—some even pulled from the customs of ancient Rome.
This illumination is based on Valerius Maximus’ Concerning Morals and Customs, a compilation of stories about ancient mores and heroes written in the 1st century A.D. You can see two sets of dining experiences, with classist and moral undertones, happening at once in this image. At the top right is the nobility, dining over a white cloth of honor, their perfect posture bordering on stiff. At the front, by contrast, a boisterous bunch of peasants gets wasted.
Nobles being noble
Partying like a peasant
Valerius (the author of the Roman text) shows Emperor Tiberius the danger of intemperance. And don’t miss this dog, who looks a bit lost in the scene.
So yeah: In the Middle Ages there was a clear concept of table manners, at least among the rich. But while the nobles are inherently better-behaved (according to this illustration paid for by nobles, anyway…), the pleasure-loving peasants don’t have it so bad. Also, if you’ve fallen completely off the table, do judgy concepts of table manners even still apply?
Detail of The Competition in Sittacene and the Placating of Sisgambis, about 1470–75, Master of the Jardin de vertueuse consolation. French and Flemish. The J. Paul Getty Museum
FALSE: Men’s clothing was always practical and functional
In a word: leggings.
Extremely wedgie-inducing, leggings-as-pants were the subject of great debate, then as now. In mid-15th-century England there was even a law about who could wear short tunics that revealed the male buttocks. Surprise! Only the rich.
More on this medieval fashion faux-pas here.
Detail of Saint Fiacre and the Shrew Houpdee, 1469, Lieven van Lathem. The J. Paul Getty Museum
FALSE: Medicine was based on pure superstition
Surgeons and doctors existed in the Middle Ages, and while some treatments were a bit scary by today’s standards (bloodletting was a thing), they were quite logical.
Then as now, many medicines were drawn from plants. Saint Fiacre, shown here, was the patron saint of gardeners and disease-sufferers, a handy combo.
(Fun fact: hemorrhoids were called “the figs of Saint Fiacre.”)
In the story that inspired this illumination, the “hey, you!” lady in the background is so amazed by Saint Fiacre’s green-thumb-slash-healing-powers that she accuses him of practicing witchcraft. But if healing and herbology sometimes seemed suspicious, healers like St. Fiacre were also thought to be doing the work of God.
Detail of Saint Jerome Extracting a Thorn from a Lion’s Paw, second quarter of 15th century, Master of the Murano Gradual, Italian. The J. Paul Getty Museum
Practical and logical home remedies, like ointments and bandaging, are also seen aplenty in pictures from the Middle Ages. In this illumination depicting the miracle of Saint Jerome removing a thorn from a lion’s paw, a frightened monk in the background rushes in with a gold bowl of ointment and a semi-sheer bandage. In the foreground, Saint Jerome casually, and elegantly, removes the splinter with a pair of gold tweezers. Just because a miracle is occurring doesn’t mean you shouldn’t stop at CVS.
Detail of The Trinity, Book of Planets, Anatomical Treatise, Liber synonimorum, shortly after 1464. German. The J. Paul Getty Museum
Also on the topic of science, in the Middle Ages astrology was hugely important. People at all levels of society were concerned with their star charts, political leaders especially so. From breaking ground for new buildings to waging battle, astrological considerations were taken very seriously. Astrology may seem superstitious to some of us, but it was practiced (some would say, is practiced) much like a science.
Details from Combat with Dagger and Staff, about 1410, Italian. Flower of Battle. The J. Paul Getty Museum.
FALSE: The most powerful military force consisted of armored knights riding into battle
Sure there were mounted members of the military, but more often than not, soldiers had to fight on the ground. A manuscript in our collection, The Flower of Battle, shows all kinds of medieval weapons, armor, and combat tactics. The picture above shows combat with dagger and staff.
Combat with staff
Check out the scary guy on the left wielding a cave-man-ish club.
Who knows, this might have been the book that taught Gandalf to fight. Because fantasy books ARE REAL…even if authors sometimes get the facts wrong.